TCEQ explains air monitoring: Organizations fear lack of testing in Port Arthur

Published 12:15 am Tuesday, December 10, 2019

The Texas Commission on Environmental Quality, along with other agencies, have monitored air quality in cities impacted by the Nov. 27 TPC Group Port Neches Operations explosions.

Testing was conducted in multiple locations in Port Arthur, a city where some citizens have complained of issues with air quality in neighborhoods surrounded by refineries. Concerns surfaced at a town hall meeting Saturday about the lack of frequency in testing in Port Arthur compared to other impacted cities, although a majority of the initial readings came from Port Arthur.

Port Arthur Community Action Network and Lone Star Legal Aid, a United Way-supported legal firm, hosted the town hall at Empowerment Church on Memorial Boulevard.

Subscribe to our free email newsletter

Get the latest news sent to your inbox

A plume of smoke traveled from Port Neches to Port Arthur in the hours following the early morning initial combustion and resulting fire. The Environmental Protection Agency reported up to 17.07 parts per million of butadiene in the work area between 2:30 p.m. Dec. 4 and 2:30 p.m. Dec. 5 and up to 12.09 ppm in the community outside the work area during the same time span.

Ryan Vise, external relations director with TCEQ, said the agency used a variety of equipment around the site and in impacted areas.

“This strategy considers factors such as wind direction, meteorological conditions, and location of plume to help assure that the monitoring occurs in communities downwind of the site,” Vise said. “Conditions have changed throughout this event and air monitoring activities are adjusted in response. The TCEQ has monitored in the Port Neches, Groves, Nederland, Port Arthur, Beaumont, Bridge City, Vidor, and Orange communities (Jefferson and Orange Counties). TCEQ will continue to conduct air monitoring until the event is over.”

The highest reading for butadiene released Monday afternoon was 0.3 ppm at 2129 Main St. in Port Neches at 10:40 p.m. Sunday. A reading of 0.5 ppm for VOC was detected in that location at the same time.

Butadiene is among the projects TPC Group houses in Port Neches and is a known carcinogen.

Vise added that the TCEQ’s Beaumont staff conducts air monitoring surveys throughout neighborhoods located near industrial sites in the Golden Triangle.

“In addition, the TCEQ also conducts monitoring in response to citizen complaints related to odors, including those alleged from industrial sources,” Vise said. “The TCEQ also monitors air quality in these communities through its stationary air quality monitoring network.  While data from these monitors can be useful during emergencies, they are sited to measure regional air quality conditions and not potential impacts from industrial incidents, such as the TPC event.”

Stephanie Thomas, an area researcher and community organizer with Public Citizen, said she is organizing a group of citizens who would like to speak at a hearing at the TCEQ commissioners’ meeting regarding TPC at 9:30 a.m. Dec. 18. The office is located at 12100 Park 35 Circle, Room 201S, Building E, in Austin. Thomas can be reached at 832-840-6464.

Thomas asks those who plan to attend to fill out a form at: The form will help to coordinate travel and sign up people in advance.

Those who cannot attend may still submit a written comment to present to the commissioners but are asked to contact Thomas for details.

Thomas asks those who want to speak to follow these guidelines:

  • Speak concisely; each person is only allowed three minutes to speak.
  • Share your story; what happened to you matters.
  • Share specific concerns or solutions.

Concerns about waivers

Port Arthur Community Action Network chairman John Beard and Lone Star Legal Aid attorney Amy Dinn warned attendees against signing any waivers that would prevent them from taking future legal action against TPC and asked them to consult an attorney, if necessary, to assess damages.

The phone number to file a claim with the Community Assistance Helpline is 866-601-5880.

“Once the claims process is complete, and a homeowner accepts estimate, claims documents that specifically reference property damage claims will be signed and payment issued,” TPC spokesperson Sara Cronin said. She did not specify whether waivers were included in the documents.

About I.C. Murrell

I.C. Murrell was promoted to editor of The News, effective Oct. 14, 2019. He previously served as sports editor since August 2015 and has won or shared eight first-place awards from state newspaper associations and corporations. He was born in Memphis, Tennessee, grew up mostly in Pine Bluff, Arkansas, and graduated from the University of Arkansas at Monticello.

email author More by I.C.