, Port Arthur, Texas


March 15, 2013

Best of West; Byars was correct on neo-plantation mentality of NCAA


Editor’s note: The following column from the Best of West Collection was first published in the Port Arthur News on May 28, 2008.    

One of the most stunning reversals of hard-nosed dogma in any arena was fashioned by Walter Byars, who was the first head of the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA), and directed it in an iron-fisted manner from 1951 to 1988.

In 1995, seven years after stepping down from overseeing the hypocritical world of the “student-athlete,” Byars literally shook the NCAA’s foundations by proclaiming it was time to start paying athletes due to the “neo plantation mentality” existing under the current system.

“In light of the hypercommercialization of today’s college athletics, dramatic changes are necessary to permit athletes to participate in the enormous proceeds,” Byars told the Kansas City Star over a decade ago. “College athletes don’t need new rules, they need new freedoms.”

To put in perspective just how dramatic a turnaround the one time NCAA czar’s words were, let’s ponder some hypothetical changes of direction from other powerful people.

• It would be like New England football coach Bill Belichick saying, “Hell yes we spied on other teams, and it gave us a tremendous advantage. Only a fool would think we would do something like that if wasn’t helping us out.”

• It would be like Roger Clemens saying, “Of course I took steroids. I was starting to lose my edge and I was willing to do whatever it took to get back to being dominant. The day I threw the bat at Mike Piazza was pure ‘roid rage.’ ”

• It would be like George Bush saying, “Sure, I lied about the reasons for starting a war in Iraq that has cost America billions of dollars and thousands of lives. I listened to the wrong people and we’ve paid a terrible price.”

• It would be like Bill Clinton saying. “Yeah, I had sex with that woman, Monica Lewinsky. Look at my history. I tend to get horny and my pick-up standards aren’t all that high.”

That brings us back to Walter Byars and why the NCAA is the topic for today’s history lesson/current events column. The movtivation is twofold.

Beyond my disgust at how the big business aspect of college sports gets passed off as amateurism,  the fact the NCAA recently got nailed in court to the tune of $218 million over short-changing their cheap labor, aka “student athletes.” begs comment.

Before we examine the ramifications, let me throw out one more Walter Byars quote. And, remember, this is a guy who saw it all from the inside, who helped implement policy, for nearly four decades.

Noting how the NCAA likes to hide behind amateurism whenever the subject of paying athletes is broached, Byars said, “Collegiate amateurism is not a moral issue. It is an economic camouflage for monopoly practice.”

Now, obviously, this discussion only peripherally touches on the Lamars, the Sam Houstons and other low and  mid major programs. This is basically about the football and basketball factories, the Texas’, the Ohio States, the Michigans, the UCSs and others in the upper echelons who generate obscene revenues off their high profile programs and, by extension, their athletes.

To make sure the profits keep rolling in, they pay mega salaries to coaches. But the labor cost is relatively minimal — 85 scholarships in football and 13 in basketball. What’s more, the NCAA has helped hold the costs in line by refusing to budge over the value of a scholarship.

Despite playing more games, and facing longer, tougher off-seasons, athletes on scholarship for years have been basically limited to tuition and fees, room and board and required books. Any other expenses incurred during the school year, a figure the NCAA places at $2,500 for the average student, were not covered.

In the meantime, the NCAA and its member schools benefit from a $6 billion TV contract on its basketball tournament, many millions in other TV and radio rights fees for football and basketball, ridiculously priced tickets and oh, yes, selling the jerseys of star players.

Said players, of course, are not entitled to any of the considerable monies generated by the jerseys. And if said players come from impoverished backgrounds and need a little spending money, well, that’s tough.

Thankfully, the plantation mentality is about to be adjusted, although not nearly as much as it needs to be.

Due to a class action lawsuit filed in 2006, on behalf of football players at Stanford and USC, and basketball players at San Francisco and Texas-El Paso, the NCAA has agreed to fork over the above-mentioned  $218 million. The money will go to football and basketball players at Division 1 schools dating back to 2002.

The $218 million will be available through the 2012-13 school year to athletes who can demonstrate a financial and/or academic need for access to the funds. Some $10 million is earmarked in chunks of $2,500 per year for expenses incurred above what a scholarship paid.

For the NCAA, the payoff could have been worse had it not agreed to settle out of court. Since anti-trust laws were invovled, damages awarded in court could have been tripled. Also worth noting is the NCAA, in the beginning, tried to play the “protecting amateurism” card, as well as the “maintaining competitive balance” argument.

Ultimately, two high powered Los Angeles law firms blew them away. The genius in their approach, according to the website site, was not requesting pay for athletes, but seeking to show that the NCAA and its members violated federal law by agreeing to artificially suppress the value of scholarships.

Somewhere Walter Byars is applauding.

Sports editor Bob West can be e-mailed at   







Text Only
  • Bassmaster Elites are coming back

    The Bassmaster Elite Series returns to Southeast Texas in March 2015 to fish out of Orange.
    The announcement was made last week, ahead of Bassmaster’s official tournament schedule announcement and the buzz is already strong in Southeast Texas and beyond.
    I was in Orlando, Fla. attending the ICAST (fishing trade) show and talked with a number of top anglers including Kevin VanDam, Mike Iaconelli and Shaw Grigsby who said it was no surprise they would return considering the massive turnout for the weigh-ins and that the area welcomed them in a very special way.
    It’s far too early to speculate anything like who the top contenders will be or how the fishing will be but there are some things to keep in mind and to look for over the next few months and into the event itself.
    • Prefishing-There is a pre-fishing cutoff that usually extends to right before the Bassmaster Classic and I fully expect most of the anglers in the Elites to come back and prefish.
    Last go-round probably 2/3 of the field fished the area but this time I expect that to be just about everyone. Many of the anglers that did not pre-fish told me they expected to have a lot of water to fish but the sheer volume and diversity was almost overwhelming.
    Beginning probably in the early fall we will see many anglers fishing local waters to get a better idea on how to approach the area.
    • East to West Runs-The Elite anglers fished far and wide but I expect even more running next go-round. After launching from the Simmons Drive Boat Ramp in Orange angler Bill Lowen ran down the Intracoastal, across Galveston Bay and fished in the Clear Lake area and placed in the top 12. The more adventurous anglers will try super long runs, in my opinion, even longer than last time to try and score on big fish. The Intracoastal Canal system makes that possible.
    • Sabine River -Very few of the anglers actually fished in the Sabine River despite the event being called the “Sabine River Challenge”. I think that will change with more anglers running as far north as they can to find pockets of fish that receive little pressure and perhaps a four or five-pounder to push them over the top.
    • Bigger Turnout-Last year some 34,000 people attended the event which set a Bassmaster record for an Elite event.
     It was broken a couple of weeks later in New York but I fully expect the 2015 tournament to draw 40,000 plus. The reason they are coming back is not for the stellar fishing because while we have lots of bass, everyone knows our fishery cannot compare to Toledo Bend for example.
    The support from the public however was amazing and that is what is bringing the top anglers on the planet to fish our area.
    We will have the very best coverage of the event beginning now and leading up to it with exclusive interviews with all of the top pros with not only their thoughts on the big event but with unique tips on how you can catch more fish.
    It’s an exciting time and I look forward to bringing you special coverage on a special event.
    (To contact Chester Moore, e-mail him at You can hear him on “Moore Outdoors” Fridays from 6-7 p.m. on Newstalk AM 560 KLVI or online at or watch him on “God’ Outdoors with Chester Moore” Saturdays at 10 a.m. on

    July 23, 2014

  • Mid County knocked out of tournament

    The Mid County 16-18 Babe Ruth squad’s run to the World Series is over.

    July 22, 2014

  • West golf notepad: West duo claims title in Texas Father-Son

    July 22, 2014

  • Mid County sets up championship series with Tri County

    The Southwest Regional Babe Ruth championship series is set and yes the hometown Mid County squad will be there to play.

    July 21, 2014

  • MC Babe Ruth goes 2-0

    First things first, give Clint Landry and the rest of the officials credit for making the Southwest Regional Babe Ruth tournament possible this weekend at Nederland High School.

    July 19, 2014

  • Up the odds for solid bank fishing

    There are certain limitations to fishing without a boat.

    July 19, 2014

  • Derek Williams, Summer Money League light up the lanes at Max Bowl

    Thursday nights Summer Money League produced some very impressive scores.

    July 19, 2014

  • West column: Pacers hiring Pat Knight didn't help Lamar

    July 19, 2014

  • Babe Ruth.jpg Mid County Babe Ruth set to host Southwest Regional

    The Mid County Babe Ruth 18U team is once again knocking on the World Series door. Mid County will host the Southwest Regional at Nederland High School starting today. Mid County’s first game of the tournament is slated for 7 p.m. Friday against Pine Bluff, Ark. Thursday was a special day for Mid County Babe Ruth as two locals, Jimmy Collins (shown speaking) and Skip Hopkins (back left) were inducated intot he Southwest Regional Babe Ruth Hall of Fame. Both Hopkins and Collins have been involved in Babe Ruth for over 40 consecutive years either as player, coach or board member. There are nine teams in the tournament with the winner headed to Washington state for the World Series.

    July 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • West golf notepad: Eleven-year-old Henry scores ace in YMBL tourney

    July 15, 2014

From the Fieldhouse blog